Augmented Reality Comparison of DIfferent Types

Augmented Reality Comparison of DIfferent Types

Oct 11, 2011

Augmented Reality

 

It’s still early in the augmented reality lifecycle, but at this time there are about three practical types of augmented reality implementations. We’re going to examine one type each day for the next three days.  The currently viable types include:

 

  1. Marker-Based
  2. Marker-less
  3. Hardware – glasses, goggles, or even contacts in the future.
In this post, we’ll take a very shallow dive into the Marked Based type of Augmented Reality.  Our goal won’t be to learn how they work yet, mostly I just wanted to let you know what types were available so you would have a frame of reference for your project.  I’ve included a link to what I think may be the best, most complete, set of tutorials for actually implementing marker-based augmented reality.  If you’re a technical type, I suspect that set of tutorials will keep you busy for a while.

Comparison of Different types of Augmented Reality

Over the next three posts, we’ll take a look at each of the three types augmented reality systems.  The one we’ll look at first is called the marked based augmented reality.

Augmented Reality – Marker Based

The race in marker based augmented reality must be on. One technology company from London who specializes in 3D work has already branded a name for the symbol it uses for the augmented reality marker.  The company, Inition, calles its version of the marker a MagicSymbol.  Let’s take a quick look at how the marker based type of augmented reality works.

Augmented Reality Marker Joseph A Moniz

First we need to take a quick look at the marker itself.  It looks a little like a QR code, but today’s Augmented Reality Marker doen’t really need to carry as much information as the QR code.  Their primary purpose is to

  1. Provide a location for the source file (URI)
  2. Provide visual feedback to the camera attached to the computer to position the card and the markings in 3D space.
While a QR code became popular because of its ability to pack data densely, the augmented reality marker’ primary purpose is more about providing the visual feedback to the camera.
If you’re a marketing professional, you might find it interesting that the shape images on the marker can be “customized”. In other words, they don’t have to look like a bar code or a QR code.  The real trick is high contrast and clearly defined points that allow the camera/computer combination to identify the position of the point in 3D space.  This opens up a world of possibilities for branding of the marker itself.

From a technical perspective, the basic computer programming tasks are to

  1. Write code that enable you to find the markers in your image or video.
  2. Write code to ensure that you have the correct marker and especially that you communicate that information from just about any direction
  3. Write code to determine the relative placement of the marker in 3D space.

Honestly, there’s very litte reason for anyone to write this code by hand.  There’s  a lot of of information and code available on the web that can help you to get started at a higher level than writing the image recognition code.  My favorite site for learning about marker based augmented reality is InstantReality.org.  They’ve done a great job of creating educational materials for those of you that want to try to build one yourself.  I’d wager that this is the most comprehensive set of understandable tutorials on Augmented Reality on the web today.

Here’s a video of a what a Marker-Based Augmented Reality Experience looks like.  Don’t be fooled, the 3D isn’t like  a hologram in 3D space.  What you’re looking at it’s the 3D model being displayed in the computer.

Augmented Reality Markerless

Tomorrow, we’ll take a look at markerless augmented reality solutions.

Hardware Based Augmented Reality

The next day, we’ll take a look at hardware: glasses, goggles, even contacts.  Honestly, the contacts are probably a ways off yet.

Until Tomorrow

 

 

VN:F [1.9.13_1145]
Rating: 10.0/10 (1 vote cast)
VN:F [1.9.13_1145]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
Augmented Reality Comparison of DIfferent Types, 10.0 out of 10 based on 1 rating